Structural Equation Modeling of the Dimensions of Place with a Cross-cultural Approach (Case study: Isfahan Naghsh-e-Jahan Square)

Document Type : Research article

Authors

1 PhD Candidate, Department of Urban Planning, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Urban Planning, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

3 Professor, Department of Urban Planning, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
The issues of place and culture can be studied within the context of human and social geography. The cultural characteristics of society (like a soul) manifest and influence the body of “place”. The city as a substrate is a cultural-physical collection formed by the needs, activities and behaviors of inhabitants. The most desirable structure of a good city should facilitate the connection between different cultures. The aim of this research is to make structural model of place dimensions in Isfahan Naghsh-e-Jahan Square with cross-cultural approach. The necessity of conducting this research is to investigate several main categories which include place, cross-cultural dimensions and the position of Naghsh-e-Jahan Square. In the category of place, the attention is focused on empirical, behavioral and practical dimensions of place in urban areas with emphasis on Iranian context and its features; in the category of cross-cultural dimension, the attention is focused on the explanation of multi-dimensional look at spatial and space categories; and in the category of Naghsh-e-Jahan Square,  the attention is focused on the importance of surveying to identify the capacities of cultural/historical places for international exploitation and cultural-social and economic strategies.
Methodology
This study has been designed in survey method, with the aim of structural relation modeling between place variables with cross-cultural approach. The model and hypothetical relationships were tested by the information gathered from visitors of Isfahan Naghsh-e-Jahan Square in nowruz holidays. In selecting people for interview; we tried to consider different characteristics such as gender, age and education. The selection of samples was done systematically and the interviews were conducted with passengers and visitors in four sides of the square and during two morning and afternoon shifts. We gathered information via researcher made questionnaire. All questions were asked on a scale of 5 options. In this study, statistical population is all the people with the age of more than 18 years old in Naghsh-e-Jahan Square and in the period of data collection. Cronbach’s alpha coefficients and factor loadings derived from confirmatory factor analysis indicate the appropriate validity and reliability of research tools. Structural equation modeling (SEM) was used to test the research hypotheses. This model includes two parts: measurement model and structural model. In order to assess the goodness of fit of the model, various fit tests such as NFI, PGFI, GFI, RMSEA, Chi-Square and PNFI have been used; the figures of all indicators show the goodness of fit of the model.
Results and discussion  
The study of statistical distribution of four dimensional locations with cross-cultural approach indicates the criterion of power-attractive capacity  with the average of 51.07 and standard deviation of 7.07 as the best situation among all criteria. This criterion was considered by respondents as a very favorable. Other criteria with favorable average values and higher indicate that Naghsh-e-Jahan Square with special location characteristics and cross-cultural approach can be considered as a favorable place. The results of correlation tests indicate that all place dimensions with cross-cultural approach have positive and meaningful relationships with each other. This shows that in terms of semantics, the quadruple dimensions of place model with cross-cultural approach have a relatively good relationship with each other; they can interact with each other in a common conceptual space. Using confirmatory factor analysis, test of the first hypothesis indicated that a place with cross-cultural approach of the raised quadruple dimensions is combined with the theoretical model of the research and the criteria of the goodness of fit based on appropriateness of confirmatory factor analysis model with research observations. The second hypothesis of this research indicates causality relationship between the factors of power persistence capacity and power- interactive and evolutionary capacity; the standardized path coefficients associated with this path express the positive and significant impact of the factor of power-persistence capacity on  power-interactive and evolutionary capacity. The third hypothesis of this research indicates causality relationship between the factors of power- persistence capacity and power-event capacity; the standardized path coefficients associated with this path express the positive and significant impact of the factor of power-persistence capacity on power-event capacity. The fourth hypothesis of this research indicates causality relationship between the factors of power- attractive capacity and power- event capacity; the standardized path coefficients associated with this path express the positive and significant impact of the factor of power-attractive capacity on power-event capacity. The fifth hypothesis of this research indicates causality relationship between the factors of power-interactive and evolutionary capacity and power- event capacity. The standardized path coefficients associated with this path express the positive and significant impacts of the factor of power-interactive and evolutionary capacity on power-event capacity. All goodness of fit indicators on the structural part of the model is as acceptable as the measurement model.
Conclusion
The place approach of this research is a new approach that has not been investigated directly. Therefore, the present research can be regarded as an innovative and creative perspective on the concept of place. This study indicates that the place with cross-cultural approach has a complex concept with different dimensions. In the current research, the four-dimensional model derived from the previous studies was tested in the format of the grounded theory. The findings of the present study express that in assessment of the respondents, the factor of power- persistence capacity isdeclined in score compared with other place dimensions with cross-cultural approach. This shows that special facilities should be provided for power- persistence capacity to convert Naghsh-e-Jahan Square to a place with cross-cultural approach. The findings indicate that among all factors of a place with cross-cultural approach, the respondents allocated the highest score to the factor of power-attractive capacity. Therefore, it can be concluded that if Isfahan Naghsh-e-Jahan square is considered as a place with cross-cultural approach, it is possible that the power-attractive capacity will be more useful. The findings indicate that the places with more possibility of interaction will probably provide better opportunity for conversion and also play the role as a place with cross-cultural approach.
 

Keywords

References

  1. Almaz^|^Aacute; N, J., Suzuki, M., Tairako, Y., Kawakubo, S., & Inoue, G. (2012). Cross-Cultural Evaluation of public space Quality. Journal of Architecture and Planning (Transactions of AIJ), 77(680), 2379-2388. http://dx.doi.org/10.3130/aija.77.2379.
  2. Aminpur, Ahmad; Jabalameli, Abdolah and Khatabakhsh, Fariba (2017). A Historical Review of Naghsh-e Jahan Square's Status of Proprietorship: From Safavid era to the Islamic Revolution according to Deeds of Endowment, Honar-Ha- Ye-Ziba: Memari-va-Shahrsazi, 21(4), 87-98 (In persian).
  3. Barati, Nasser (2015). Semiotic-cultural Definition of “Place” (Case Study: Persian Language), Journal of the Art and civilization of the ORIENT, 3(8), 3-10 (In persian).
  4. Bigdeli, Zahed and Sharifi, Somayeh(2008). An Introduction into the Concept of place, Library and Information Science, 11(4), 239-254(In persian).
  5. Cultural Heritage Organization (2008). Naghsh-e-Jahan: Eternal legacy, Media narratives of immortality of an architectural masterpiece, Ghalmro Aftab publication, first edition, Tehran(In persian).
  6. Ebrahimpour, Farshid ( 2015). Naqsh-e Jahan Square: A masterpiece in this world, Naqsh-e Negin publication, first edition, Isfahan(In persian).
  7. Ebrahimpour, Farshid ( 2018). Ālī Qāpū of  Naqsh-e Jahan: A masterpiece in half of the world, Naqsh-e Negin publication, first edition, Isfahan(In persian).
  8. Ghasemi, Vahid (2013). Structural Equation Modeling in Social Researches Using Amos Graphics, Sociologists Publication, second edition, Tehran(In persian).
  9. Ghashghaee,  Reza; Movahed, Khosro and Mohammadzadeh, Hojatollah (2016).Evaluation of sense of place with an emphasis on physical and environmental factors in urban coastal areas; Case study: Boushehr Town, Journal of Geography and Urban Planning Research, 4(2), 261-282(In persian).

10. Golkar, Koroush (2011). Creating Sustainable Place: Reflections on Urban Design Theory, Publication of Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran (In persian).

11. Habib, fereshteh(2009).The interaction between culture and urban Physical; Case Study: Esfahan-Safavid, ,Hoviat-e-shahr 3(4), 83-94.

12. Hair, J., Sarstedt, M., Ringle, C. and Mena, J. (2011). An assessment of the use of partial least squares structural equation modeling in marketing research. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 40(3), pp. 414-433.

13. Haghighi, Mohsen, Nassrin; Ghaleehnoee, Mahmoud; Ghaffari, Abbas (2017). Assessing the Effective Elements of Acoustic Comfort and Soundscape Imageability of Users in the Naghsh-e-Jahan Square, Isfahan, Journal of Architecture And Urban Planning, Bi-Annual Journal of University of art, 5(19), 133-151(In persian).

14. Hosseini, Seyed Yaghoub and Abareshi, Ahmad (2012). Structural Equation Modeling, Sociologists Publication, first edition, Tehran(In persian).

15. Khastou, Maryam and Habib, Farah (2017). An Analytical Approach to the Impact of urban Physical Aspects on Culture emphasizing Urban Fabric; Case Study: City of Qazvin, Journal of Studies on Iranian-Islamic City, 7(26), 31-42(In persian).

16. Kottak, P.C.(2002). Anthropology: The Exploration of Human Diversity, McGraw-Hill Higher Education Publication, United States.

17. Mehrabani, Elena; mansouri, seyed amir and javadi, shohre (2017). Landscape Approach in Creating Vitality in Valiasr Avenue with Emphasis on Creating the Sense of Place. A Case Study of Valiasr Avenue (The Distance between Vanak Square and Parkway Intersection), Bagh-e Nazar Quarterly Journal, 14(55), 5-16(In persian).

18. Mirgholami, morteza and ayashm, masoumeh (2016). A conceptual model to evaluate the sense of place using four factors of perceptual, physical, social and functional; the Case study of Imam Street in Urmia, Journal of urban Studies: Motaleate Shahri, 5(19),69-79(In persian).

19. Modiri, Atousa (2008). Place, Hoviat-e-shahr, 2(2), 69-79(In persian).

20. Montgomery, J. (2008). The new wealth of cities. Aldershot [u.a.]: Ashgate.

21. Naqizadeh, Mohammad(2016). Contemplations on Cultural Transactions regarding Ideas and Idioms, Case Study: Space and Place, Journal of Iranian Architecture Studies, 1(8),89-106(In persian).

22. Naqizadeh, Mohammad(2015). Identity of The City: Foundations, Components & Manifestations, Jahad Daneshgahi Publication, First Edition, Tehran(In persian).

23. Ostovar, Nima; Behzadfar, Mostafa; Zamani, bahador; Ghale noee, Mahmood (2015). Mixed method research of effective factors on temporality in urban place/ Naghsh-e-Jahan Square Isfahan, Journal of urban Studies: Motaleate Shahri, 4(16), 39-53(In persian).

24. Pakzad, Jahanshah (2010). An Intellectual History of urbanism, From space to place, Armanshahr Publication, Second Edition, Tehran(In persian).

25. Pakzad, Jahanshah (2011). Theoretical foundations and urban design process, Shahidi Publication, fifth edition, Tehran(In persian).

26. Panjtani, Monireh; Mansourian, Yazdan and Mobini, Mahtab (2017).Phenomenology of the Aesthetic Experience of place: Case Study Naqsh-e-Jahan Square, Journal of Philosophical Investigations, 11(20), 23-60(In persian).

27. Rad Ahmadi, Mina (2012). The study of the evolution and the continuity of Naghsh-e-Jahan square (Imam square) in Isfahan with emphasis on its open space, Master thesis in Environmental Graphic, Advisor professor: Tehrani, Farhad, Isfahan University of Art, June 2011(In persian).

28. Rezvani, Mohammad Reza and Ahmadi, Ali (2010). Place and role of culture in the formation of spatial identity, Journal of Culture-Communication Studies, 10(6), 45-68(In persian).

29. Shafieian Dariani, Faezeh; Pour Jafar, Mohammad Reza and Ghobadi, Alireza  (2014). The Concept of Persistence in Islamic Architecture and comparing it to the Concept of Sustainability in Contemporary Architecture, Journal of Researches in Islamic Architecture, 2(4), 32-50(In persian).

30. Shahabian, Pooyan and Larimiyan; Seyedeh Farzaneh (2016). Survey on Soundscape of Valiasr Street in Tehran with Emphasis on a Human Perception, Armanshahr journal, 9(17), 237-248(In persian).

31. Shahabi Nejad, Ali; Abouie, Reza and Ghaleehnoee, Mahmood (2016).Climatic Comfort in Naqsh-e Jahan Square, Journal of Studies on Iranian-Islamic City, 7(25), 5-16(In persian).

32. Shahabi Nejad, Ali; Abouie, Reza and Ghle Nouie, Mahmood and Imami, Seyed Mohammad (2014). Formation and Historic Revolution of Isfahan s Naghsh-e-Jahan Square, Bi-Annual Electronic Journal of Restoration Science & cultural Heritage, 2(3), 45-65(In persian).

33. Shamai, S. (1991). Sense of place: an empirical measurement. Geoforum, 22(3), 347-358. http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/0016-7185(91)90017-k.

34. Shayan, Hamidreza; Einifar, Alireza and Diba, Darab (2009). Design Concepts in Alien Context Analyzing Foreign Architects’ Works in Persian Gulf States from the Perspective of Regionalism, Honar-Ha- Ye-Ziba: Memari-va-Shahrsazi, 1(38), 49-60(In persian).

35. Shokouhi, Hossein (2005). New thoughts in the philosophy of geography: Environmental philosophy and geographic schools, Gitashenasi Geographical & Cartographic Institute, Tehran(In persian).

36. Sholeh, Mahsa; Lotfi, Sahand and Kian, Fariba (2017). Application of ‘Place Design Quality Indicator’ (PDQI) Method in the Comparative Assessment of Historic and Cultural Urban Spaces Case Study: Two Historic-Cultural Places in Historic Urban Fabric of Shiraz, Journal of Architecture And Urban Planning, Bi-journals of the University of Art, 10(19), 31-114(In persian).

37. Steele, Fritz (1981). The Sense of Place, CBI Publishing Company, Boston.

38. Thomas, D. F. and Cross, J. E. (2006). Organization as place builders. Institute of Behavioral and Applied Management, Available at: http://www.stoveprairiegroup.com/oapd.pdf (accessed at 17th May).

39. Vahdat, Salman and  karimimoshaver, Mehrdad (2016). Comparative study on the opinions of specialists and citizens to transform urban environments into social teaching spaces; Case study: Hamadan, Journal of Geography and Urban Planning Research, 4(1), 89-116(In persian).

40. Zare, Mozhgan (2011). The study of visual factors in Ali qapu mansion and its use in Environmental Graphic of Isfahan Naghsh-e-Jahan square, Master thesis in Visual Communication, Advisor professor: Ghazizadeh, Khashayar, Shahed University, August 2011(In persian).

41. Zekavat, Kamran and Sadat Dehghan, Yasaman (2017). Dimension to Develop Quality in Public Realm and a Management Model for Creation of Places, Armanshahr journal, 9(17), 215-224(In persian).

Geographical Urban Planning Research (GUPR)
Volume 6, Issue 1
April 2018
Pages 149-174

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics